Email us today!
Owning a Tesla in Michigan comes with unique insurance challenges that can surprise even experienced drivers. While electric vehicles (EVs) are becoming more affordable to insure overall, Tesla models, especially the popular Model Y, continue to see rising premiums. Understanding why these costs are higher and how Michigan’s insurance landscape affects Tesla owners can help you make smarter coverage decisions.
Recent data shows that electric vehicle insurance premiums dropped by 23% nationwide in 2025 after years of being 40 to 60 percent more expensive than gas-powered cars. Yet, Tesla insurance premiums have bucked this trend, increasing at twice the market rate due to repair complexities and vandalism risks
Somainsure,
Electrek. This guide breaks down what Tesla owners in Michigan need to know about insurance coverage, costs, and strategies to manage premiums effectively.
Why Tesla Insurance Costs More in Michigan
Tesla vehicles are known for their cutting-edge technology and safety features, but these same qualities contribute to higher insurance premiums in Michigan. The state’s no-fault insurance system means drivers pay for their own medical expenses regardless of fault, which can drive up overall costs. For Tesla owners, the situation is compounded by several factors:
- Higher Repair Costs: Tesla parts and repairs are more expensive than those for traditional vehicles. Battery electric vehicles (BEVs) have an average collision repair claim severity of over $6,200, compared to just over $5,000 for internal combustion engine vehicles Mitchell.
- Claim Frequency: The Tesla Model Y, the most popular Tesla model in Michigan, had the highest insurance claim frequency among EVs at 31.43% in 2024 Mitchell International.
- Vandalism Risks: Tesla vehicles face increased vandalism, which has pushed premiums higher. This risk is especially pronounced in urban areas of Michigan Electrek.
These factors explain why the average annual insurance cost for Tesla vehicles in Michigan is $5,252, more than double the $2,352 average for all vehicles in the state Insurance.com. Tesla owners need to be prepared for these higher costs when budgeting for insurance.
Michigan’s No-Fault Insurance System
Michigan requires no-fault auto insurance, which covers your medical expenses regardless of who caused the accident. While this provides strong protection, it also increases premiums, especially for vehicles with higher repair costs like Teslas. The system also means that bodily injury claims are less common, but property damage and repair claims still drive rates up.
For Tesla owners, the combination of expensive repairs and medical coverage requirements means insurance companies charge more to offset potential losses. Understanding this system helps explain why Tesla insurance costs remain elevated despite falling EV premiums elsewhere. Additionally, the unique nature of Tesla's technology, including its advanced driver-assistance systems, can lead to more complex claims, further complicating the insurance landscape. Insurers may also need to invest in specialized training for adjusters to accurately assess damages on these high-tech vehicles, which can contribute to higher operational costs that are ultimately passed on to consumers.
Moreover, the growing popularity of electric vehicles in Michigan means that more drivers are entering the market, potentially leading to increased competition among insurance providers. However, the intricacies of insuring a Tesla—such as the need for specialized repair facilities and parts—mean that while competition may drive prices down for some vehicles, it may not have the same effect for Tesla owners. As the electric vehicle market continues to evolve, it will be interesting to see how these dynamics play out and whether insurance premiums will adjust accordingly in the future.
By: John G. Growney
President of Oakland Insurance
How Tesla Model Y Insurance Premiums Compare Nationally
The Tesla Model Y is the best-selling EV in the U.S., but it also leads in insurance claim frequency. In 2024, it had a 31.43% claim frequency, the highest among electric vehicles Mitchell International. This contributes to premium increases that far outpace the national average.
Year-over-year, Model Y insurance premiums rose 29%, nearly three times the national average increase Insurify. This surge is driven by repair costs, vandalism, and high accident rates among early high-performance EV adopters, according to insurers Somainsure.
Repair Costs and Insurance Impact
Electric vehicles require specialized parts and technicians, which raises repair costs. Tesla’s proprietary technology means repairs often must be done at Tesla-certified facilities, adding to expenses. The average collision repair claim severity for BEVs exceeds $6,200, compared to just over $5,000 for traditional vehicles Mitchell.
Higher repair costs translate directly into higher premiums. Insurance companies adjust rates to cover these expenses, which is why Tesla owners pay more despite the safety features that reduce injury claims. Additionally, the unique design of the Model Y, which includes advanced sensors and cameras for its Autopilot features, can complicate repairs further. This complexity not only increases the time and cost of repairs but also contributes to a higher likelihood of claims, as more intricate systems can lead to more potential points of failure.
Moreover, the growing popularity of the Model Y has led to an uptick in theft and vandalism incidents, which also play a significant role in rising insurance premiums. With its sleek design and cutting-edge technology, the Model Y has become a target for thieves looking to capitalize on its high resale value. Insurers are now factoring in these risks when determining premiums, leading to even steeper costs for owners. As the EV market continues to evolve, it's essential for potential buyers to consider these factors when evaluating the total cost of ownership for a Tesla Model Y.
Strategies to Manage Tesla Insurance Costs in Michigan
While Tesla insurance premiums in Michigan are high, there are ways to manage costs without sacrificing coverage. Here are some practical tips:
1. Shop Around and Compare Quotes
Not all insurers price Tesla coverage the same. Comparing quotes from multiple companies can reveal significant savings. Some insurers offer discounts for EVs or have partnerships with Tesla service centers that lower repair costs. Additionally, it’s worth checking if your current insurer provides any loyalty discounts or incentives for bundling policies, such as home and auto insurance, which can further reduce your overall premium.
2. Adjust Coverage Levels Wisely
Review your coverage limits and deductibles carefully. Increasing your deductible can lower premiums, but be sure you can afford the out-of-pocket cost if you file a claim. Avoid skimping on liability coverage, especially in Michigan’s no-fault system. It’s also beneficial to evaluate optional coverages like comprehensive and collision insurance, as they can be adjusted based on the vehicle's age and current market value, ensuring you’re not over-insured.
3. Consider Usage-Based Insurance
Some insurers offer pay-per-mile or usage-based insurance programs that reward safe driving. If you do not drive your Tesla extensively, these options could reduce your premium. Furthermore, many of these programs utilize telematics technology, which tracks your driving habits and can provide insights into how to drive more safely, potentially leading to even greater discounts over time.
4. Protect Against Vandalism
Given the rising vandalism claims for Teslas, investing in security measures like garage parking, surveillance cameras, or alarm systems can help. Some insurers offer discounts for enhanced vehicle security. Additionally, consider joining local community watch programs or online groups focused on Tesla ownership; these networks often share tips on neighborhood safety and may even provide access to local resources for vehicle protection.
5. Maintain a Clean Driving Record
Insurance companies heavily weigh your driving history. Avoiding accidents and traffic violations can keep your premium from climbing further. Moreover, participating in defensive driving courses can not only enhance your driving skills but may also qualify you for additional discounts with certain insurers. Keeping abreast of local traffic laws and regulations can further ensure that you remain a safe and responsible driver.
Understanding the types of coverage available helps Tesla owners tailor their policies to fit their needs and budget. Here are key coverage options to consider:
| Coverage Type | What It Covers | Why Tesla Owners Need It |
|---|---|---|
| Liability | Covers bodily injury and property damage to others if you cause an accident. | Required by law; protects your finances from lawsuits. |
| Personal Injury Protection (PIP) | Medical expenses for you and passengers regardless of fault. | Mandatory in Michigan’s no-fault system; covers medical bills after crashes. |
| Collision | Repairs or replacement if your Tesla is damaged in a crash. | Important due to high repair costs for Teslas. |
| Comprehensive | Covers non-collision damage like vandalism, theft, or natural disasters. | Protects against rising vandalism risks affecting Tesla vehicles. |
| Uninsured Motorist | Covers damages if hit by a driver without insurance. | Critical in Michigan, where uninsured drivers rose from 12.4% to 15.4% between 2018 and 2023 Insurance Research Council. |
Michigan’s Unique Coverage Requirements
Michigan’s no-fault law requires Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage, which can be costly but ensures medical bills are covered promptly. Tesla owners should also consider uninsured motorist coverage given the rising number of uninsured drivers in the state. Balancing these requirements with collision and comprehensive coverage tailored to Tesla’s repair costs is key to effective protection.
In addition to the basic coverage options, Tesla owners in Michigan should also be aware of the potential benefits of adding optional coverages to their policies. For instance, gap insurance can be particularly valuable for Tesla owners who finance their vehicles. This coverage helps bridge the gap between what you owe on your car loan and the actual cash value of your Tesla in the event of a total loss. Given the rapid depreciation of electric vehicles, gap insurance can provide peace of mind and financial security.
Moreover, many insurance providers now offer specialized policies that cater specifically to electric vehicles. These policies may include perks such as discounts for low mileage or incentives for using Tesla’s advanced safety features. As the market for electric vehicles continues to grow, Tesla owners should take the time to explore these tailored insurance options that not only meet their needs but also potentially save them money in the long run.
How Tesla’s Safety Features Affect Insurance
Tesla vehicles come equipped with advanced safety features like Autopilot, collision avoidance, and over-the-air updates. These technologies can reduce accident severity and frequency, which should theoretically lower insurance premiums.
However, insurers note that early adopters of high-performance EVs, including Teslas, have experienced higher accident rates. This has tempered the expected premium reductions. Over time, as these technologies mature and driver behavior adapts, insurance costs may better reflect Tesla’s safety benefits Somainsure.
One of the standout features of Tesla's safety technology is its ability to learn from real-world data. Each Tesla on the road contributes to a vast pool of information that helps improve the algorithms behind Autopilot and other safety systems. This continuous learning process not only enhances the vehicle's performance but also provides valuable insights to insurers about driving patterns and risk factors. As more data becomes available, insurers may be able to develop more accurate models for predicting risk, potentially leading to more personalized insurance rates based on individual driving behavior.
Moreover, Tesla’s commitment to safety is evident in its rigorous testing and crash ratings. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has awarded Tesla vehicles top safety ratings, which can influence consumer perceptions and, consequently, insurance premiums. As the market for electric vehicles expands, insurers may also begin to consider the overall safety reputation of brands like Tesla when setting rates, further complicating the relationship between safety features and insurance costs. This evolving landscape suggests that both consumers and insurers will need to stay informed about advancements in automotive safety technology and their implications for insurance pricing.
Wrapping Things Up: What Michigan Tesla Owners Should Remember
Insurance for Tesla vehicles in Michigan is complex due to the state’s no-fault system, high repair costs, and unique risks like vandalism. While electric vehicle insurance premiums have generally fallen recently, Tesla insurance rates continue to rise, especially for the Model Y.
Being aware of these factors can help Tesla owners make informed decisions about coverage and cost management. Shopping around, adjusting coverage thoughtfully, and investing in security can all help control premiums. Staying up to date on Michigan’s insurance rules and Tesla-specific risks will ensure you have the protection you need without overpaying.
For more detailed insights on Tesla insurance trends and how they impact Michigan drivers, check out the latest
Insurance.com report and
industry analyses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Why is Tesla insurance more expensive in Michigan than in other states?
A: Michigan’s no-fault insurance system and higher repair costs for Teslas contribute to increased premiums compared to other states.
Q: Can I lower my Tesla insurance premium without reducing coverage?
A: Yes. Consider shopping around, using usage-based insurance, and improving vehicle security to reduce premiums.
Q: Does Tesla’s Autopilot reduce insurance costs?
It can help lower accident severity, but early data shows higher accident rates among some Tesla drivers, so the impact on premiums varies.
Q: What coverage is mandatory for Tesla owners in Michigan?
Liability and Personal Injury Protection (PIP) are required under Michigan law. Uninsured motorist coverage is also highly recommended.
Q: How does vandalism affect Tesla insurance rates?
Rising vandalism claims have increased Tesla insurance premiums, especially in urban areas where such incidents are more common.
Q: Are there discounts available for insuring a Tesla?
Some insurers offer discounts for EVs, safe driving, bundling policies, and enhanced security features.
Q: Is it worth carrying collision and comprehensive coverage on a Tesla?
Given the high repair costs and vandalism risks, collision and comprehensive coverage are important to protect your investment.
About The Author:
John G. Growney
As President of Oakland Insurance, I bring over 25 years of experience in every aspect of the insurance industry — from customer service to sales and agency management. As a Licensed Insurance Counselor (LIC) and Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC), I’m dedicated to helping clients make confident decisions about their coverage. I earned my B.A. in Business from Michigan State University and currently live in Clarkston, Michigan with my two children and our rescue dogs.
Tesla Insurance
Your Business Insurance Solutions
Workers Comp Insurance
Workers' compensation insurance is a type of insurance that provides benefits to employees who are injured or become ill as a result of their job. These benefits may include medical expenses, lost wages, and disability payments.
COMMERCIAL AUTO INSURANCE
Commercial auto insurance is a type of insurance that covers vehicles used for business purposes. This includes cars, trucks, vans and other vehicles owned by a company and used by employees for work-related activities.
PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY
Professional liability insurance, also known as errors and omissions insurance, is a type of insurance that protects businesses and individuals from financial losses resulting from claims of professional negligence or failure to perform professional duties.
BUSINESS OWNERS POLICY (BOP INSURANCE)
Business Owners Policy (BOP) insurance is a package policy that combines general liability insurance and property insurance for small and medium-sized businesses. It is designed to provide coverage for common risks such as property damage, liability claims, and business interruption.
Our Process
Oakland Insurance has an efficient, customer-focused approach when working with business owners looking for business insurance in Michigan.
1. Consultation
This begins from the moment a business owner reaches out for business insurance. Our business mindset helps us approach every consultation process as an opportunity to learn about a business and its needs, so we can recommend the best business insurance coverage that fits their situation.
2. Insurance Options
We take pride in our attention to detail: from fine-tuning insurance plans to contacting multiple competing carriers, we ensure our clients receive effective business insurance solutions tailored to their unique goals and operations.
3. Claims
We know that the claims process can be complex and time-consuming. That’s why Oakland Insurance works with clients to file and track their claims quickly and efficiently, so they can get back to running their businesses with minimal disruption.
4. Customer Service
Oakland Insurance provides ongoing support and advice to clients who have questions about their business insurance policies or need additional coverage. Our experienced team is dedicated to helping our clients make informed decisions regarding their commercial insurance needs.
Contact us today to get started!
Industries Served In Michigan
Electrician
Insurance
Electricians typically need liability insurance to protect themselves from claims of property damage or bodily injury caused by their work.
Contractor Insurance
General contractors typically need workers' compensation insurance to cover medical expenses and lost wages for any on-the-job injuries.
Carpenters Insurance
Carpenters may need workers' compensation insurance to cover medical expenses and lost wages for any on-the-job injuries.
Auto Dealer
Insurance
Automobile dealer's may need physical damage insurance to cover damages to the vehicles on their lot and garage liability insurance to cover any injuries that occur on their premises.
Commercial Buildings Insurance
Commercial building owners typically need property insurance to protect their building and contents from damage or loss due to covered perils such as fire or theft.
Hotel & Motel Insurance
Hotels & Motels typically need may also need liability insurance to protect themselves from claims of bodily injury or property damage caused by their operations, and workers' compensation insurance to cover medical expenses and lost wages for any on-the-job injuries.
Cost of Business Insurance in Michigan
The cost of business insurance in Michigan can vary depending on a number of factors, including the type of business, its size, location, and the level of coverage needed. Some of the most common types of business insurance policies in Michigan include general liability insurance, property insurance, workers' compensation, and professional liability insurance.
General liability insurance is typically required for most businesses and can protect against claims of bodily injury or property damage caused by your business operations. The cost of this coverage can range from a few hundred dollars per year for a small business to several thousand dollars per year for a larger business.
Property insurance is another important type of coverage for businesses in Michigan and can protect against damage to buildings, equipment, and inventory. The cost of this coverage can vary depending on the value of the property and the level of protection needed.
Workers' compensation is mandatory for most businesses in Michigan and can protect against claims made by employees who are injured or become ill as a result of their work. The cost of this coverage is typically based on the number of employees and their salaries.
Professional liability insurance is often required for businesses that provide professional services, such as consulting or legal advice. This type of coverage can protect against claims of negligence or errors and omissions. The cost of this coverage can vary depending on the type of business and the level of protection needed.
Overall, the cost of business insurance in Michigan can vary widely depending on the specific needs of the business. It is important to work with a reputable insurance agent who can help you determine the right coverage for your business and provide you with competitive quotes.
Why Choose Us
Oakland Insurance offers comprehensive small business liability insurance in Michigan. Our experienced team will take the time to understand a client’s needs and provide tailored solutions that meet their unique requirements.
We offer competitive rates and have access to numerous carriers, so we can work with our customers to help them get the best coverage for their budget. Our commitment to providing exceptional customer service means we are always available for advice and support when needed.
Testimonials
What Our Commercial Insurance Clients Are Saying
